|
Getting Your
Message Across: Schools have been in the business of drug education for over one
hundred years. But it was not until the mid 1970s that research began to show which
approaches worked --- and which did not --- to prevent problems with tobacco, alcohol or
other drugs. One of the strategies that has been closely evaluated is the information
model. Prevention research has been clearly established that programs
which depend solely on providing information about health, social and legal risks of
tobacco, alcohol or other drug use are ineffective. However, providing accurate
information in combination with other strategies can result in measurable changes in
attitude and behavior. As school activity staff members, there are ten factors you
should keep in mind when teaching about tobacco, alcohol or other drugs:
Be confident of your expertise The credibility of the person giving the information is
significantly related to the learner's willingness to accept the messages given. Research
seems to indicate that an "outside expert" is not necessary in communicating
about sensitive issues such as tobacco, alcohol or other drug use. Other factors --- such
as familiarity to students, trustworthiness, attractiveness --- may be more significant.
School activity staff members often have these characteristics in their relationships with
young people and can be powerful messengers. Research has shown that two-sided messages are more effective
than one-sided messages. A one-sided message concentrates on only they negative effects of
tobacco, alcohol or other drugs, and ignores any potential benefits of their use. Young
people who are only exposed to information about the negative side effects of tobacco,
alcohol or other drug use will be unprepared to counteract the information they get from
their friends or other sources about the possible benefits. The students' role in learning the information is also
important. As with any other subject, active learning about tobacco, alcohol or other
drugs is superior to passive learning. Young people need and want opportunities to talk
about tobacco, alcohol or other drugs with adults they trust. School activity staff
members can provide these opportunities. Multiple sources are superior to single sources. When young
people hear the same positive messages from several sources --- their friends, their
parents, classroom teachers, coaches, athletic directors, other school activities staff,
clergy, law enforcement personnel and other significant adults --- they are more likely to
accept the message. It is easy to give mixed messages about tobacco, alcohol or
other drugs. For example, some schools have invited sports heroes or popular performers
who are ex-users to speak to young people. The speaker encourages young people --- by his
or her words --- to not use tobacco, alcohol or other drugs. And yet he or she was able to
achieve success while using drugs, and even now is gaining attention by telling stories of
drug use. Young people respond more to information about short-term
consequences than long-term ones. For instance, young people are more likely to avoid
smoking because of bad breath than because of the potential for lung cancer. Approaches that attempt to scare young people away from a
particular behavior don't seem to have any long-term impact. The aura of infallibility
that surrounds most adolescents protects them from believing that anything bad could ever
happen to them. Many adolescents watch their peers use --- or use themselves --- without
apparent consequences. In this case, scare tactics only serve to discredit the presenter
of the information. Advertisers have long known that our behavior as consumers
strongly influenced by hearing and seeing brief, captivating commercials that are repeated
many times. We can emulate this strategy by taking advantage of teachable moments to send
brief, positive messages about not using tobacco, alcohol or other drugs. Young people tend to believe, and act on the misperception, that
"everybody is doing it." Instead, promote the fact that most young people choose
not to use tobacco, alcohol or other drugs. Use trend data that clearly show how tobacco,
alcohol or other drug use is declining. Messages promoting the use of tobacco, alcohol or other drugs
are pervasive in our society. Although some messages are direct, most are subtle. These
subtle messages suggest that tobacco, alcohol or other drug use is associated with fame,
fortune or success in athletics or other pursuits. Often these messages promote both use
and misuse of drugs, including underage consumption of tobacco and alcohol. The alcohol industry spends nearly $2 billion a year on
advertising and promotion. Beer companies alone spend more than $675 million, most of it
on TV ads that appear during sporting events. These messages reach a large number of young
viewers. The average American youth will see literally thousands of beer commercials
before he or she reaches the legal minimum drinking age. Although we cannot shelter young people from all messages that
promote the use of tobacco, alcohol or other drugs, we can challenge these messages. We
can use many opportunities to encourage young people not to use tobacco, alcohol or other
drugs, including those drugs which can alter performance. As school activity staff members, you are
frequently confronted with situations that involve tobacco, alcohol or other drugs. Rule
infractions, widely published (or rumors of) underage drinking parties, and inappropriate
use by celebrities are just a few examples of teachable moments. Positive behavior can
also be recognized and used as a teachable moment. These situations range from close
personal times when young people confide in you, to situations involving groups of young
people, to opportunities for counteracting larger societal messages. All are
"teachable moments." By thinking ahead, you can formulate the messages you want
to send when these opportunities occur. |